21p -22.5p would be about right. The engine has a max rpm of 4400 -4800. First thing I would do is, if the prop isn't damaged, then leave it. Take the boat out on the water and get it up on plane. Once trimmed out, go to Wide Open Throttle (WOT) and see where your max rpm is. If the max RPM is between 4400 - 4800 then leave it alone.
If the RPM is over 4800, increase pitch
If the RPM is below 4400, decrease pitch.
(1" pitch = 200 rpm)
I suspect you're probably right in the sweet spot. The test is assumed that you are neither overloaded, nor under loaded. Empty water, near empty fuel, no gear is going to behave much differently than full gear, 8 people and 2 loaded coolers. Keep the weight avg.
You could try going through the Mercury Prop calculator. It was giving me some issues when I tried to run through with limited info.
https://www.mercurymarine.com/us/en/...eller-selector