Have you checked iBoats? You can get a nice shiny new one for just over $100.
http://boatpropellers.iboats.com/Mer...t_id=011309330
Personally I would go for the $115 one (the Solas Rubex) with the interchangeable hub. Then if you trash it again, you can buy just the prop (no hub) for $80.
You may also want to check your local prop shop. They probably have some new and used ones that they may sell.
__________________