Paul welcome aboard
I guess the old engine taught you
As Roger suggested see what WOT the new engine is getting with the current prop. He is also correct about adding an inch of pitch will cause ~200 rpm decrease. Switching to a SS prop of the same pitch will also drop the rpms.
If you were not happy before you may be now as the new engine has more HP and torque.
PS: don't argue with the wife you'll loose that one as well